Hits: 0
Is torture ever morally permissible debate
For our term paper, your goal is to write a paper of roughly 1,500 words in which you take a stance on a philosophical debate.
You should select one of the following debates:
- Is torture ever morally permissible?
Consider the following case (adapted from Judith A. Boss’s Ethics for Life), and evaluate it from utilitarian and deontological perspectives: In 2003, Pakistani forces and the CIA captured Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, a suspected terrorist whom they thought to have information that would endanger the American public. In order to retrieve information, US personnel used “enhanced interrogation techniques” on Mohammed, including sleep deprivation, rectal rehydration, and waterboarding. Later, in 2006, President George W. Bush proposed legislation that would Is torture ever morally permissible debate Help “decriminalize the use of cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment by civilian interrogators (Links to an external site.)”, thereby permitting the use of torture on suspected terrorists. Is the use of enhanced interrogation techniques morally justified? (In discussing deontology, make sure to discuss the idea of autonomy.) - How strong of a moral obligation do we have to give to those in need (e.g., famine relief)?
Peter Singer argues that we are obliged to give up to the point at which giving more would make us worse off than those we are trying to help. In contrast, a Kantian can argue that we shouldn’t give so much such that we sacrifice our autonomy.
- Is it ever morally justified to commit an act of civil disobedience? Is torture ever morally permissible debate Help
In the Crito, Socrates offers several arguments against civil disobedience, whereas in the “Letter from Birmingham Jail” MLK defends some instances of civil disobdience.
To write a successful paper on your chosen topic, you need to carry out the following tasks.
Task 1: Give an overview of the two competing views, and explain each side’s argument(s).
Task 2: Present your position on the debate, and offer reasoning of your own in support of your position. You should both present reasoning in support of your position and raise objections to the opposing side’s view/arguments.
Task 3: Present one objection to your own argument/view, and defend yourself in response.
For Is torture ever morally permissible debate Help please click here